My mom came to visit me this past weekend and she had several requests. After drooling over my blog, she wanted to visit some great restaurants, and she wanted nice weather. Lucky for her, the sun was shining all weekend. I also had some restaurant choices up my sleeve, and hoped they would turn out as good as the weather.
For our first night, we decided to try Al Forno. I'd heard mixed reviews about this Italian restaurant near the water. Some people said it was a must-try, others said it had gone down the tubes since the chefs changed. I decided I wanted to form my opinion. Al Forno is one of the most famous restaurants in Providence, and I thought this blog, and myself, would benefit from the opportunity to critique it.
We arrived at 6:45 pm. The host rudely informed us it was at least a two hour wait, but we put our name down anyway and decided that by the time we found another restaurant, the wait would be at least an hour, and thus our wait time would be similar. I also overheard a woman say, when her friend balked about the 2 hour wait, "they always say it's two hours." So I figured that meant Al Forno has a reputation for purposely over-estimating their wait times. We luckily got a seat at a bench in the upstairs bar and had a nice chat over a drink and a basket of bread. After about an hour and fifteen minutes, the rude host came to inform us our table was ready.
We were seated at a nice table downstairs. Admittedly, it is a beautiful restaurant and very lively. We were happy to have a nice waitress because we were worried that after both a bad host and a bad bartender, we would be facing similar service for the rest of our meal.
We started with the margarita pizza, which thankfully came out quickly because we were starving:

First of all, it is a huge appetizer. But we had to try the infamous wood-grilled pizza! It was as good as I expected. It had a very thin and very crispy crust, fresh garlicky tomato sauce, and the perfect amount of cheese. The julienned basil on top was perfectly fragrant and tasty and we had to stop ourselves from eating more than one small piece. We had a lot more food to save room for!
Then we tried the caesar salad:

This was not good at all. It was doused in a terrible dressing that tasted like over-ripe lemons and little else. The only thing redeemable were the croutons- fresh pieces of buttered bread lightly toasted. My mom and I ate only a couple bites and decided we couldn't even stand it. We figured it was better, because our pasta dishes were bound to come out soon and we wanted to save room.
Little did we know we were going to wait almost 45 minutes after the salad was taken away for our pasta course. When it finally arrived, we were both annoyed and tired (it was almost 10 at this point). I had the gnocchi in a sausage sauce:

This was actually very good. I thought the portion size was perfect, the sauce had a lot of nice chunks of sausage, and the gnocchi was tender. I ate the whole thing up.
My mom had the rigatoni with lamb ragu:

She also thought hers was good. It was a basic lamb ragu, nothing special, but enjoyable.
For dessert (which you have to order with your entrees) we had the apple tart:

While this looks very pretty and delicious, it wasn't. The crust was buttery and sugary, so it was tolerable, but the inside was not. The green apples had their skins left on, and were sliced very thin. You had to separate all the skin from the rest of the tart before eating it or the stringy pieces of green skin got stuck in your throat or between your teeth. It made the whole thing difficult to chew and the skins also left a nasty aftertaste if you accidentally put some in your mouth. This dessert was also $20- a complete waste of money.
At 10:30 when we were driving home, we discussed our meal. This was our consensus: was the food generally good? Yes. Was it 2-hour wait and very expensive good? No. If this had been a quick meal at a humble Italian restaurant with moderate prices, I probably would have raved about the place. But seeing as we waited an hour and fifteen minutes to be seated, and then an additional almost two hours for our main course, then paid a fortune for it all, I am not inclined to rave about Al Forno at all.